Back to blog

AI Share of Voice

Nearly 3 of the top 5 AI-recommended brands change once you leave New York and English

Nearly three of the top five brands ChatGPT and Gemini recommend change once a buyer moves away from New York and English, according to a September 2026 study of 1,200 identical purchase questions. The pattern is sharpest in payments and HR software, and the two AI models often don't even agree with each other.

Louis Foweraker · ·

Nearly three of the top five brands that ChatGPT and Gemini recommend change once a buyer moves away from New York and English, according to a September 2026 study from marketing firm FTA Global. The report ran 1,200 tests across 10 business categories, in cities from New York to Mumbai and in seven languages. Of the 206 brands that appeared in its answers, 77% showed up in only one country. For a brand tracking a single global AI Share of Voice score, that gap sits entirely outside the dashboard.

What FTA Global's Context Report actually tested

FTA Global's Context Report covered 10 business categories, including CRM, payroll, accounting, payments, and HR and recruiting, and asked ChatGPT and Gemini the same purchase questions from different cities and in different languages. FTA describes it as an agency study, with the full method and data available on request from its report page.

Payment software shows the pattern most clearly. Asked which payment gateway to use from a New York, English-language account, both models named Stripe, Square and PayPal. Asked the identical question from Mumbai, the answer became Razorpay, Cashfree and PayU, a list that shared not one brand with the New York result.

Why payment and HR brands swing more than everyday software

Not every category moved by the same amount. According to FTA Global's release, payment-related categories averaged 4.4 of the top five recommended brands changing across the cities tested, compared with 1.5 for everyday categories such as video conferencing and cloud storage, and no top US HR software brand appeared in any other country tested.

That split tracks how local the underlying vendor landscape actually is. A payment processor has to connect to a country's own banks, card networks and currency rules, and an HR platform has to handle that country's payroll tax and employment law, so the correct answer genuinely changes from one market to the next. A project management tool or a video conferencing app works close to identically everywhere, so geography has less to change.

ChatGPT and Gemini do not even agree with each other

Location was not the only source of disagreement. Asked the identical question in the identical city, ChatGPT and Gemini shared only about 3.2 of the top five recommended brands on average, per the same release, and the same question gave the same top brand only 35% of the time.

That cross-model gap matches a pattern BrightEdge's analysis of five AI engines already found: the engines agreed on which brands to recommend only 36% to 55% of the time, with the overlap dropping even lower in categories like healthcare, as detailed in our comparison of how AI engines rank the same brands differently.

A brand that looks strong in ChatGPT and barely visible in Gemini is not necessarily losing ground. It may simply be seeing one engine's version of an answer that was never going to match the other's.

Academic research backs up the pattern

The geographic effect is not unique to FTA Global's data. A paper posted to arXiv in April 2026 built LocQA, a benchmark of 2,156 questions across 12 languages, and tested it against 32 language models to expose hidden geographic and cultural defaults.

LocQA's results showed that when a question's locale was left ambiguous, models fell back on default assumptions about which country's laws, dates, units of measurement or institutions applied, assumptions that did not always match the language the question was asked in. That lines up with what FTA Global measured: ChatGPT and Gemini default toward answers shaped around their biggest, best-documented market, English-speaking and American, and only partly adjust once a different country or language is specified.

Why a single AI Share of Voice score hides all of this

A single global AI Share of Voice number cannot show which cities or which languages it was actually measured in, and most brands never ask. Tool vendors are starting to account for it: Semrush expanded its AI visibility prompt database to 32 countries in May 2026, arguing that AI search is not a single-market phenomenon.

The formula for measuring AI Share of Voice works the same way in every market; what changes is which prompts, cities and languages you run it against, and most brands still run it against exactly one.

It is a familiar shape of blind spot. The same instinct that produces one global score is also what leaves trackers skipping Mistral and DeepSeek entirely, or weighting every engine equally after Comscore measured ChatGPT's US share falling 20 points, a shift covered in our analysis of engine weighting.

What to actually test before trusting one score

The fix is not a new metric, it is a wider test. Running the same purchase questions in the cities and languages where actual buyers search, rather than relying on English-only testing from one location, is what exposed the gap in the first place.

Categories with heavier local regulation, payments, HR, insurance, financial services, deserve market-by-market checks before a brand trusts a blended score for them. Everyday software categories can likely stay on a lighter testing schedule, since FTA Global's data showed far less movement there. In Germany, where the release reports that AI engines pulled 42% of their cited sources from German-language web pages, a brand with no German-language content is working against the local source pool before a single ranking factor comes into play.

Frequently asked questions

Does AI Share of Voice vary by country?

Yes. A September 2026 study by FTA Global found that nearly three of the top five brands ChatGPT and Gemini recommend changed when a purchase question moved from New York and English to another city or language, across 1,200 tests run in several cities and seven languages.

Why do payment and HR software categories show the biggest geographic differences?

FTA Global's study found payment-related categories averaged 4.4 of the top five recommended brands changing across markets, compared with 1.5 for categories like video conferencing and cloud storage. Local banking rules, currencies and employment law likely explain the gap, since those factors genuinely differ by country while general software mostly does not.

Do ChatGPT and Gemini recommend the same brands for the same question?

Not reliably. FTA Global found the two models shared only about 3.2 of the top five brands on average for identical questions asked in the same city, and a separate BrightEdge analysis found AI engines agree on brand recommendations only 36% to 55% of the time overall.

Can a single global AI Share of Voice score capture this variation?

No single score can show it. Semrush expanded its AI visibility prompt database to 32 countries in May 2026, citing the need for market-level data, and FTA Global's research shows that testing only one city or language can miss most of a brand's real exposure elsewhere.

What should brands do differently when tracking AI visibility across markets?

Run the same purchase questions in the cities and languages where actual buyers search, rather than relying on English-only, US-based testing alone. Pay closest attention to categories like payments, HR, and financial services, where FTA Global found recommendations change the most between markets.

Related articles

Brand Visibility

How to track brand mentions in Microsoft Copilot, starting with Bing's citation report (2027)

Bing Webmaster Tools tells you, for free, how often Copilot cites your pages. This guide shows what that report counts, what it leaves out (brands named without a link, answers given at work) and how to fill the gaps with prompt checks and GA4.

Louis Foweraker ·

Brand Visibility

Google AI Overview tracking: find the keywords that trigger one, then the brands it names (2026)

Tracking Google AI Overviews starts with keywords, not prompts: an overview appears on about a quarter of US queries, and far more often on long informational ones. This guide shows how to record the trigger, the linked sources and the brands named without a link, and what Search Console and rank trackers leave out.

Louis Foweraker ·

Brand Visibility

Best AI visibility tools for small businesses in 2026: 11 affordable options compared

Many AI visibility tools start at $95 a month or more. Here are the 11 best options for a small business on a budget, with who each one suits, its real monthly cost, its pros and cons, what its users report and the free checks to run before you pay for anything.

Louis Foweraker ·

Brand Visibility

AI visibility tracking tools under €50 a month: 2026 comparison

At least six plans track how AI assistants mention a brand for €50 a month or less. We checked each vendor's pricing page on 9 November 2026 and compared what the money buys: prompts, AI engines and how often they are checked.

Louis Foweraker ·

Optimize your presence across Generative AI and Answer Engines.

Track your AI visibility · Get a demo